playbooks
Instantly Setup Guide for AI Agencies
A practical Instantly setup guide for AI agencies covering ICP, domains, inboxes, campaign structure, reply routing, deliverability, and measurement.
On this page
This setup guide is for AI agencies that want to use Instantly without turning outbound into a messy volume game. The goal is a controlled system: clear ICP, healthy sending infrastructure, segmented campaigns, fast reply handling, and learning that improves both sales and content.
Step 1: Define the Campaign Before the Tool
Do this before logging into any platform:
| Setup item | Example |
|---|---|
| ICP | B2B SaaS companies with 20-100 employees |
| Workflow pain | Repetitive support ticket triage |
| Offer | AI helpdesk triage audit |
| Proof | Before/after workflow map or client example |
| CTA | “Should I send a short teardown?” |
| Qualified reply | Prospect owns support or operations and wants details |
If the offer is vague, the campaign will be vague.
Step 2: Prepare Domains and Inboxes
Set up sending domains and inboxes carefully:
- Use domains that are appropriate for outbound.
- Configure SPF, DKIM, and DMARC.
- Confirm MX and reply routing.
- Use consistent sender identities.
- Keep business-critical transactional email separate from cold outreach.
- Ramp slowly and watch reputation signals.
This is where many agencies rush. Do not.
Step 3: Build Segments
Do not upload one giant list. Build segments that create useful learning:
| Segment | Why it exists |
|---|---|
| High-fit niche | Tests the core offer |
| Trigger-based list | Tests timing relevance |
| Past-client lookalikes | Tests proof transfer |
| Tool-stack segment | Tests integration angle |
Each segment should have its own hypothesis. Otherwise you cannot learn from replies.
Step 4: Create the First Campaign
The first campaign should include:
- One primary email.
- Two follow-ups.
- One clear CTA.
- One proof point.
- One unsubscribe process where required.
- Conservative sending limits.
Keep copy plain. The prospect should understand the business outcome before they understand the AI mechanism.
Step 5: Route Replies
Before launch, decide who owns each reply type:
| Reply type | Owner | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Interested | Founder or sales lead | Reply same day |
| Referral | Founder or assistant | Ask for correct owner |
| Not now | Sales lead | Set follow-up date |
| Objection | Founder | Save wording for content and copy |
| Unsubscribe | Operations | Suppress immediately |
Reply handling is part of the campaign, not an afterthought.
Step 6: Review After 7-14 Days
Do not rewrite everything after one day. Review enough data to see a pattern:
- Which segment produced qualified replies?
- Which subject lines created actual conversations?
- Which objections repeated?
- Which proof points were requested?
- Which leads were clearly wrong?
- Which campaign should be paused?
Then update the offer, list criteria, and content plan.
FAQ
What should an AI agency set up before Instantly?
Before Instantly, define the ICP, offer, reply owner, proof point, compliance posture, and what counts as a qualified reply.
How many campaigns should a new AI agency launch?
Start with one or two narrow campaigns. Too many campaigns at launch makes it hard to understand which message or segment is working.
What should Instantly measure first?
Measure positive replies, qualified replies, booked calls, no-shows, and closed revenue before optimizing for open rates.